The Christian gospels repeatedly disagree – with each other!

In my book, 201 Things About Christianity You Probably Don’t Know (But Ought To), I give dozens of examples where the four official Christian gospels disagree with each other. ‘Luke’ even disagrees with himself (since he also wrote Acts of the Apostles).

Those who say G_d wrote or inspired the Bible are shooting themselves in the foot. Does G_d get its fact wrong or contradict itself? It seems so.

There are many possible reasons why the gospels frequently disagree; you may be able to think of a few of your own. They include:

  • Chinese Whispers: the stories were passed down orally to each of the authors leading to distortions, exaggeration and inaccuracies.
  • They each researched the stories separately and uncovered different facts.
  • They selected those parts of the story which appealed to them, such as ‘Matthew’ preferring the myth of the Wise Men in the nativity stories and ‘Luke’ the shepherds.
  • None of them had all the facts, being separated from the events by time, language and distance.
  • They were more concerned with making theological points than getting the factual details right.
  • Each gospel author had a different agenda and chose only those facts which fit.
  • They used artistic licence to create a convincing argument and/or good story. In other words, they made some of it up!

Perhaps it’s all of the above!

Many years ago a journalist shared with me the guiding principle of his profession: ‘Never let the facts get in the way of a good story.’ The gospel authors were undoubtedly better journalists than historians! The evidence is right there in the pages of the New Testament itself.

©David Lawrence Preston, 25.8.2015

Facebook and Twitter

Follow me on Facebook and Twitter, @David_L_Preston

Front cover 201 things

Balboa Press, 2015




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *